Quick Verdict
Both are AffiniPay-owned platforms targeting small general practice firms. MyCase at $109/user/mo edges ahead on client communication and simplicity. PracticePanther at $89/user/mo is more affordable with stronger built-in billing. Neither offers PI-specific workflows or meaningful AI.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Criteria |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $109/user/mo (annual commitment for discount) | $89/user/mo (annual commitment for discount) |
| Contract | Annual for best pricing | Monthly and annual options |
| Migration Cost | Self-service migration tools | Self-service migration tools |
| Best For | Simplicity-focused small firms | All-in-one with billing |
| Firm Type | Solo to Small | Solo to Small |
| AI Depth | Basic | Basic |
Key Differences
MyCase and PracticePanther are siblings under the AffiniPay umbrella, but they differ on price and emphasis. PracticePanther at $89/user/mo is $20/user/mo cheaper than MyCase at $109/user/mo — that is $2,400/year for a 10-user firm. MyCase leads with simplicity and a stronger client communication portal. PracticePanther offers more depth in billing, payment processing, and automation workflows. Both have basic AI capabilities that do not extend to substantive legal tasks. Neither platform offers contingency fee tracking or plaintiff-specific features, making them general practice tools only.
Strengths of Each
MyCase
- Cleaner, more intuitive interface
- Better client communication portal
- Faster onboarding experience
- Solid general practice workflows
PracticePanther
- $89/user/mo — $20/user/mo cheaper than MyCase
- Stronger built-in billing and payments
- Monthly billing available — no annual lock-in required
- Good mobile experience
Ideal Use Cases
MyCase
Solo and small general practice firms that prioritize simplicity and strong client communication tools.
PracticePanther
Small firms that want the most affordable integrated billing and payment processing in a case management platform.
Final Recommendation
Choose MyCase if client communication and interface simplicity are your top priorities and the $20/user/mo premium is justified. Choose PracticePanther if you want the most affordable all-in-one option with strong billing. Plaintiff litigation firms should look at purpose-built alternatives rather than either of these general practice platforms.